Is a non-working woman compelled to submit to a man? And do men fear independent women? And is it permissible for a wife to interact with her husband based on this thinking in marital life in Islam?
The statement "A woman without a job is subservient to men" is incorrect, for qawamah (guardianship/maintenance) and wilayah (authority) are religious obligations that include caring for and financially supporting the woman, as stated in the verse: (Men are guardians over women by what Allah has preferred some of them over others and by what they spend from their wealth).
As for the statement "A working woman is respected by men," it contradicts both reason and reality, because a woman's work often leads to degradation, not respect. She moves from voluntary subservience to her husband to involuntary subservience to her manager, and from her husband's endearment to harassment from colleagues.
Global statistics indicate that working women are exposed to psychological and physical abuse at a higher rate, and that most working women hold low-paying and low-status jobs.
Nevertheless, Islamic law permits a woman to work out of necessity, with religious guidelines that preserve her dignity. It also permits her to engage in spiritual works that elevate her status, such as inviting people to Allah, charity work, and teaching.
In conclusion: These statements reveal ignorance of the status of women in Islam, which honors them and elevates their standing.
Summarized from the full answer at Ftawy · reviewed Sep 2, 2026
Read the full answer on Ftawyhttps://ftawy.com/en/questions/19853