Does divorce occur when the wife leaves her family's home without her husband's permission, while the husband was hesitant between telling her "Stay with them" and "You are divorced" as a condition for her departure, and he does not recall his intention at that time?

Summary: If you prevented your wife from going out without your permission, and then clarified to her that you meant to prevent her when her family was present, and you made her divorce contingent on her going out alone, and you did not intend divorce or you intended to scare her, then she went out alone, no divorce occurs, because she did not go out while her family was present. However, if you generally prevented her from going out without your permission, then your subsequent exception is not valid because it is not connected. But as long as you are unsure whether the divorce was made contingent by implication or explicitly, your divorce does not occur with doubt.